Terms · Dispute Resolution Policy
Dispute Resolution Policy
Part of the BNTYFUL Terms and Conditions. The app shows this document when you create, claim or dispute a bounty. See also the Arbitration Agreement.
Last updated: 09-11-2026 · Effective: 09-11-2026
This Dispute Resolution Policy (this "Policy") establishes the procedures, timelines, and rules governing the resolution of disputes between Users on the BNTYFUL platform (the "Platform"). This Policy is incorporated by reference into the BNTYFUL Terms and Conditions (https://www.bntyful.com/terms/) and the Arbitration Agreement.
1. Overview of Dispute Resolution Tiers
BNTYFUL employs a tiered dispute resolution system designed to resolve disputes at the lowest appropriate level:
Tier 1 - Automated Resolution: Disputes that are resolved automatically by the on-chain program without human intervention (e.g., auto-Pass when no disputes are filed, auto-refund on expiration).
Tier 2 - Arbitrator Decision: The BNTYFUL Arbitrator reviews the Claimant's proof, the Disputers' explanations and other relevant information and records a binding Pass or Fail decision on-chain.
Tier 3 - Platform-Level Escalation: For disputes between Users and BNTYFUL (not between Users regarding a specific Bounty), disputes may be escalated to AAA arbitration as provided in the applicable Terms of Service.
2. Initiating a Dispute (Challenging a Claim)
2.1 Who May Dispute.
Any User of the Platform may file a Dispute challenging the validity of a Claim during the Dispute Window. You do not need to be the Bounty Creator, a Contributor, or have any prior relationship with the Bounty.
2.2 How to Dispute.
To file a Dispute, the Disputer must: (a) navigate to the active Claim on the Platform during the Dispute Window; (b) deposit Dispute Collateral meeting the minimum requirement (the higher of a configured percentage of remaining unmatched collateral or a fixed floor amount); and (c) provide a written explanation, of up to 500 characters, of why the Claim should fail, citing specific deficiencies in the proof. The explanation is shown publicly; there is no separate evidence upload.
2.3 Dispute Matching Threshold.
Arbitration is triggered only when the aggregate Dispute Collateral from all Disputers exactly matches the Claimant Collateral. Until the matching threshold is reached: (a) the Dispute Window continues; (b) additional Disputers may contribute; (c) partial Dispute deposits do not individually trigger arbitration. If the Dispute Window expires without the aggregate Dispute Collateral reaching the matching threshold, all Dispute deposits are refunded in full and the Claim proceeds as an auto-Pass. For a Bounty without collateral, there is no matching threshold: the first Dispute that meets the minimum dispute floor triggers arbitration.
2.4 Minimum Dispute Protections.
Each individual Dispute deposit must meet the minimum threshold to prevent nuisance or griefing disputes. The minimum is the higher of: (a) a percentage of the remaining unmatched collateral, as configured by the Platform; or (b) a fixed minimum floor amount. Dispute deposits below the minimum are rejected by the on-chain program.
3. The Dispute Window
The Dispute Window is the period following a Claim submission during which Disputes may be filed, of the duration then configured on-chain and displayed for that Claim. During this window:
(a) The Claim is publicly visible on the Platform along with the Claimant's Proof Hash;
(b) Any User may review the Claimant's proof (by opening the Claimant's proof links);
(c) Any User may deposit Dispute Collateral to challenge the Claim;
(d) The Claimant may not withdraw or modify their Claim or proof;
(e) The Reward Pool and all collateral remain locked in escrow;
(f) If the matching threshold is reached at any point during the window, the Dispute Window closes and the Arbitration Window begins immediately.
4. The Arbitration Window and Review Process
4.1 Arbitration Window.
Once arbitration is triggered, the Arbitration Window begins, running for the duration then configured on-chain and displayed for that Claim. During this period:
(a) The Claimant's proof links and the Disputers' written explanations are available for review;
(b) The Arbitrator reviews them and the relevant Bounty terms;
(c) The Arbitrator records a Pass or Fail decision on-chain before the window expires.
4.2 Evidence Review Standards.
The Arbitrator evaluates Claims against the following standard: Does the Claimant's proof, on a preponderance of the evidence, demonstrate that the Bounty's stated completion criteria have been satisfied? The Arbitrator considers:
(a) The specific completion criteria stated in the Bounty's description;
(b) The Claimant's submitted proof links;
(c) The Disputers' written explanations challenging the proof's validity;
(d) Any technical verification (e.g., timestamp verification, platform API data);
(e) The Proof Hash integrity (whether the on-chain hash matches the submitted proof links), on Bounties that require collateral.
4.3 Decision Recording.
The Arbitrator records the decision on-chain as either Pass or Fail. The on-chain program: (a) verifies the decision is from the authorized Arbitrator wallet; (b) verifies the decision is within the Arbitration Window; (c) verifies a Proof Hash exists (required for Pass decisions on Bounties that require collateral); (d) makes funds collectable according to the fixed outcome rules described in the Arbitration Agreement; and (e) closes the Claim.
4.4 Failure to Decide.
If the Arbitrator does not record a decision before the Arbitration Window expires, the on-chain program automatically applies the Expired/No-Fault outcome: all collateral is returned, the Reward Pool is refunded, and no fees are charged. This protects Users from indefinite limbo. Users cannot force the Arbitrator to decide within the window; the no-fault refund path is their recourse.
5. Claimant and Disputer Rights During Dispute Resolution
5.1 Claimant Rights.
During the dispute resolution process, the Claimant has the right to: (a) receive notification that a Dispute has been filed against their Claim; (b) view the Disputers' written explanations (subject to the BNTYFUL Privacy Policy); (c) have their Claimant Collateral held in escrow pending resolution; and (d) receive the no-fault refund if the Arbitrator fails to decide within the Arbitration Window.
5.2 Disputer Rights.
During the dispute resolution process, each Disputer has the right to: (a) submit a written explanation in support of their Dispute; (b) have their Dispute Collateral held securely in escrow pending resolution; (c) receive their Dispute Collateral back if the Claim fails (plus, where the Bounty requires collateral, their pro-rata share of the Claimant's forfeited collateral); (d) receive a full refund of their Dispute Collateral if the dispute does not reach the matching threshold or if the Expired/No-Fault outcome occurs.
6. Prohibited Conduct in Dispute Resolution
The following conduct is prohibited and may result in account sanctions:
(a) Filing frivolous or vexatious Disputes with no reasonable basis;
(b) Submitting false, fabricated, or materially altered evidence;
(c) Attempting to contact, influence, bribe, or intimidate the Arbitrator;
(d) Colluding with other Users to manipulate Dispute outcomes;
(e) Using the Dispute system to harass, retaliate against, or pressure other Users;
(f) Filing Disputes to delay payment rather than to challenge proof validity;
(g) Creating multiple accounts (sybil attacks) to artificially increase Dispute Collateral;
(h) Submitting Claims with fabricated or manipulated proof.
7. Timeline Summary
Dispute Window: from Claim submission, for the duration configured on-chain and displayed for that Claim.
Arbitration Window: from arbitration trigger, for the duration configured on-chain and displayed for that Claim.
Decision appeal period: 30 days (limited grounds only, per the Arbitration Agreement).
8. Escalation to AAA Arbitration
The on-chain arbitration system resolves disputes between Users regarding specific Bounties and Claims. For disputes that: (a) are between a User and BNTYFUL (rather than between Users); (b) involve allegations of Arbitrator misconduct, fraud, or bias; (c) challenge the validity of the Arbitration Agreement itself; or (d) are otherwise outside the scope of the on-chain system, Users may escalate to binding arbitration administered by the American Arbitration Association (AAA) under its Commercial Arbitration Rules, as provided in the applicable Terms of Service. The seat of AAA arbitration shall be Houston, Texas.
9. Modifications
BNTYFUL may modify this Policy upon thirty (30) days' notice. Active Disputes continue under the Policy in effect at the time the Dispute was filed.
10. Contact Information
For dispute resolution inquiries:
BNTYFUL Group USA LLC
Houston, Texas, United States of America
Email: contact@bntyful.com
